Corrections to incorrectly formatted Music Video titles not getting approved

  • 1
  • Problem
  • Updated 8 months ago
  • Solved
According to the IMDb Submission Guide for Music Videos, music video titles should have the format "Artist/Band: Title (year) (V)" ("i.e. Taylor Swift: Bad Blood (2015) (V)")

Over the past year, I have had multiple submissions where I am correcting incorrectly formatted music video titles so that they will match the submission guide format, yet these submissions do not get approved.

191202-050405-834000: "Hawaii (2017) (V)" should be "Kahleo: Hawaii (2017) (V)"
190927-153027-570000: "Turbo killer (2016) (V)" should be "Carpenter Brut: Turbo Killer (2016) (V)"
190917-033724-337000: "It's Okay to Cry (2017)" should be "Sophie: It's Okay to Cry (2017) (V)"
190916-140148-808000: "AFI: 17 Crimes (2013)" should be "AFI: 17 Crimes (2013) (V)"
190915-064857-241000: "The King by the Crazy World of Arthur Brown (2019) (V)" should be "The Crazy World of Arthur Brown: The King (2019) (V)"
190913-225133-208000: "Eating Out (2016) (V)" should be "Reformed Whores: Eating Out (2016) (V)"
190904-231159-693000: "The Ember Days (2018) (V)" should be "The Ember Days: Without Love (2018) (V)

For some submissions even prior to these, I have written to the help desk after more than 2 weeks past without my submission going through, but I should not have to keep waiting for my submission to fail & writing to the help desk when my submissions are about making titles that are incorrect to be correct per IMDb's own Submission Guide.

For the most recent decline, 191202-050405-834000: "Hawaii (2017) (V)" the decline reason provided in the Beta Contribution Tracker does not even make sense:

"Reason Duplicate

We were unable to approve this contribution.

The item you have submitted is exactly the same as a submission that you have already entered, which is still pending review by our staff.

Please remember that all updates submitted to IMDb are not immediately available online but must first be checked and processed by our data editors. The time it takes us to do this can vary, please see this guide for more information. If you have already submitted this item previously, please use the Track Contribution option on that submission reference instead."

I have never submitted any previous correction for this IMDb title, so there is no way my submission can be "exactly the same as a submission that you have already entered"

The rest of the submission all are from before title changes were tracked in the Beta Contribution Tracker, so I don't even have access to any "reasons", all I know is that the corrections never took place even though weeks/months have gone by.


It makes no sense that IMDb would be rejecting submissions that are designed to fix incorrect entries so that they match IMDb's own Submission Guidelines.
Photo of Vincent-P

Vincent-P

  • 62 Posts
  • 32 Reply Likes

Posted 8 months ago

  • 1
Photo of Elizabeth

Elizabeth, Employee

  • 1168 Posts
  • 1911 Reply Likes
Hi Vincent, thanks for flagging this, I've circled back with the appropriate team to review this moving forward. 
Photo of Vincent-P

Vincent-P

  • 62 Posts
  • 32 Reply Likes
Thank you for your response.  When can I expect the corrections I have listed above to be made?
Photo of Jaime

Jaime, Employee

  • 707 Posts
  • 968 Reply Likes
Hey there,

Thank you for your message.

I have submitted this  request on your behalf now, if no problems are encountered this should update online within 24 hours on all platforms.

Have a great day.
Photo of Vincent-P

Vincent-P

  • 62 Posts
  • 32 Reply Likes
Thank you!