Batwoman deleted review

  • 2
  • Problem
  • Updated 1 month ago
  • Solved
My Bat woman review witch was voted the most useful with over 2000 votes has disappeared. It was up and running since the first day of the show and has vanished in the last week. 
What's up with that?  
Photo of Ian Lambert

Ian Lambert

  • 3 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes

Posted 1 month ago

  • 2
Photo of NVanKerr

NVanKerr

  • 90 Posts
  • 149 Reply Likes
Would I be correct in assuming that your review included criticism of the "reverse sexism" that oozes from that show?

If so, I'm not surprised... my review of the "reverse racist" Black Lightning was also removed.
Photo of Ed Jones(XLIX)

Ed Jones(XLIX)

  • 20992 Posts
  • 24822 Reply Likes
Please, could you post your original contribution number here.
You can find that 18 digit number here at,
https://contribute.imdb.com/contributions/history
Thanks, it will help staff locate that review for review.
Photo of Ian Lambert

Ian Lambert

  • 3 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
#191007-091951-703904
Photo of Ed Jones(XLIX)

Ed Jones(XLIX)

  • 20992 Posts
  • 24822 Reply Likes
Thanks.
Wait for a reply by staff.
24-72 Hours.
:):)
Photo of Elizabeth

Elizabeth, Employee

  • 892 Posts
  • 1467 Reply Likes
Hi Ian, you attempted to slide by our policy on swear words by replacing one of the letters in the word. This is still a breach of our policy on the intent for reviews on the site and your review was removed. In addition, please keep in mind that reviews are a space for reviewing the actual content of a title, not personal opinions on casting, etc. 
Photo of Ed Jones(XLIX)

Ed Jones(XLIX)

  • 20992 Posts
  • 24822 Reply Likes
Thanks for being so quick!
Photo of Ian Lambert

Ian Lambert

  • 3 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
For an Amazon employee,,civilities seems to be lost on you straight to an accusatory tone instead of" Hi, after reviewing your..." " I hope the was helpful." 

I'll break down your points like a review.

1- I did use a foul word. It slipped. In my over 50 reviews, it's the first time. You could have asked to make a correction and I would have happily obliged.

2- "keep in mind that reviews are a space for reviewing the actual content of a title not a personal opinion on casting.."
How is a review not a personal opinion? This is the definition from Cambridge dictionary "If critics review a bookplayfilm, etc. they write their opinion of it".

3- My personal opinion Of Ruby Rose was that I liked her in John Wick. But that shouldn't matter as this is my opinion in my review.

4- My review was a breakdown of the first episode act by act. 

5- Maybe you didn't like my opinion of the show and that is more likely as over 2000 people found it useful and it was up for months before as zealot reported it for the bad word and you decided that this was reprehensible. 

6- You could have just said " The word is violating the TOS. Please, address this issue."

7- I suspect foul-play here. 

Here is the review in full. 

First of all, loved Ruby in John Wick. It goes like this.
1-Opens up with environmental conscientious native American (Got to cover all your bases.).
2- The police has been replace by private security because we all know "Police equals bad/ oppression.".
3- There are 6 white males in the show. 2 are evil and 4 are incompetent ;)
4- Let's move on to lesbian stereotypes (One is manlike and the other one is a princess in distress.)
5- The army/ west point persecution of gays (but in reality they were AWOL on the base and got caught.).
6- Breaking and entering justified by "It's ok. It's my cousin's house." (I will try that with the cops next time I want something in my cousin's house.)
7- Daddy issues "You are just a girl." ( Like a dad trying to protect his children is persecution.).
8-Chinese female rebel operates an illegal clinic in a basement because society doesn't take care of the poor.
9- Steals Batman's equipment because he abandoned her ( A little entitled if you ask me.).
10- Kick everybody's ass because "Girl power" you know.
11- Interminable moralistic speeches (We got it girl. The world is not fair).
12- Black male reduced to a week sidekick job because we all know that LGBTQ trumps black people unless they are part of LGBTQ. In that case they get back on top of the list. That was just the content of the show.
Now to the technical aspect. People who can't act. Terrible CGI and fight scenes that have so many cuts (like Taken because Liam Neeson can't do fight scenes anymore). It reminded me of Captain Marvel (But Captain Marvel didn't come out.). In conclusion, this is dog "chit".Ok, this was bad. Breakdown in order in spoilers.

-ReasonNot specified
Your contribution has been declined.We did not capture a specific reason during processing. 

 
     
Photo of Elizabeth

Elizabeth, Employee

  • 892 Posts
  • 1467 Reply Likes
Hi Ian, to further clarify, our policy regarding expletives is applied regardless of how many reviews you've previously submitted. The review was removed in violation of our policy. Feel free to review our guidelines for further information.
(Edited)