Appeal of declined contributions: Date of births (Requested message to Elizabeth)

  • 1
  • Problem
  • Updated 2 months ago
  • Solved
  • (Edited)
Hello Elizabeth, 

I have tried to submit as many date of births and five celebrities for propose true date of births are still declined and I was heartbroken. In relation of three previously posts entitled: Natalie Brown's date of birth found from TV Guide and more evidence Part 2Dominique Provost-Chalkley's date of birth from film related database websites as evidence and Thomasin McKenzie's full date of birth found from Issue Magazine. All of these previous posts that has URLs and photos of the actual date births that are already highlighted I previously post them and explain my comments to the editors and it was still pending and I was upset that one of the editors press the "Declined" button and said "Unable to verify" because the editors ignored the photos, ignored my explanation and ignored the true date of births and I never got my addition rejected in the first place and I was scared for getting declined. So all of the respected date of births are very true. So could you check the previous posts that has URLs and photos of the actual of the true date of births. Now, could you double check the submission numbers, the photos of actual true date of births that is highlighted and the respected URLs.

Natalie Brown: 
191020-205147-584000
191111-033911-398000
191116-051530-356000

Here are a few pictures Natalie Brown's actual date of birth is highlighted for its evidence. (please double check and zoom in to see) : 
:



Natalie Brown's few resepective URLs from contribute numbers (look at the highlighted true date of births):
https://web.archive.org/web/20160725035246/http://www.tvguide.com/celebrities/natalie-brown/296740/
https://n.noovie.com/people/natalie-brown-18261
https://www.aceshowbiz.com/celebrity/natalie_brown/filmography.html

Dominique Provost-Chalkley:
191111-045751-481000
191116-050108-928000

Here are a few pictures Dominique Provost-Chalkley's actual date of birth is highlighted for its evidence. (please double check and zoom in to see) : 




The resepective URLs from contribute numbers (look at the highlighted true date of births):
https://www.moviefone.com/celebrity/dominique-provost-chalkley/20282786/main/
https://n.noovie.com/people/dominique-provost-chalkley-160964
https://www.allmovie.com/artist/dominique-provost-chalkley-p798309

Thomasin McKenzie:
191105-011437-073000
191116-044525-942000

Here are a few pictures Thomasin McKenzie's actual date of birth is highlighted for its evidence. (please double check and zoom in to see) : 

Note: This is Thomasin McKenzie's own personal data sheet from an interview. Her actual date of birth is written by the actress herself with her own printing courtesy of Issue Magazine.

Now the other pics with actual date of births highlighted:



The URLs for Thomasin's actual date of birth:
https://issuemagazine.com/thomasin-mckenzie/#/
Image version: https://issuemagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Thomasin-McKenzie780.jpg
https://nettv4u.com/celebrity/english/movie-actress/thomasin-mckenzie
https://www.famousfix.com/topic/thomasin-mckenzie

Madeleine Mantock:
191116-042504-125000

Here are a few pictures Madeleine Mantock's actual date of birth is highlighted for its evidence. (please double check and zoom in to see) : 





The URLs for Madeleine's actual date of birth:
https://www.moviefone.com/celebrity/madeleine-mantock/20229666/main/
https://www.myseries.tv/person/153554-madeleine-mantock/
https://www.movienco.co.uk/stars/madeleine-mantock/

And Finally Samantha Logan:
191116-081314-805000 (both full name and date of birth)

Note: This is Samantha Logan's full name and date of birth already highlighted for its evidence. (please double check and zoom in to see) : 


Now the other pics with actual date of births highlighted: 




The URLs for Samantha's actual date of birth:
https://www.tvsa.co.za/actors/viewactor.aspx?actorid=15473
https://www.tvovermind.com/samantha-logan/
https://www.wattpad.com/371077279-you-can%27t-hide-%E2%96%B8-poc-fc-book-three-samantha-logan
https://www.famousfix.com/topic/samantha-jade-logan (Full name and date of birth highlighted)

I guess that is all of them. So, Elizabeth when I submit any date of birth try not post a recent date of birth submission while it's still pending. I know all of the celebrity's date of birth are all true and it should have not been declined because the editors ignore the photos, ignore my explanation and not looking at the highlighted date of births. I am 100% positive that all of the celebrity's date of births are true and should have been approved but not declined. A possible resubmission if all problems are solved on my behalf. Elizabeth look at my previous posts, look at the URLs, then the photos with a highlighted color and the previous submission numbers to double check all of them until it's all solved and the resubmit my contributions on my behalf. So thanks for the message and I am very sorry to post it recently resulting the answer is still pending so wait patiently. Submit it first and If declined take the old submission number to post it here for double check. Thanks Elizabeth I will look forward to your reply in 24 hours for an answer. See you next time.
Photo of ian_a

ian_a

  • 62 Posts
  • 21 Reply Likes

Posted 2 months ago

  • 1
Photo of Elizabeth

Elizabeth, Employee

  • 660 Posts
  • 1083 Reply Likes
Hi ian, thank you for reaching back out about this, however please know the sources you are providing do not meet our standards. We encourage you to review our birthdate guidelines and read through the types of sources we are looking for. Once you have those, you can resubmit with that evidence, and follow up with us via our private message system with any concerns. 
Photo of ian_a

ian_a

  • 62 Posts
  • 21 Reply Likes
Hi Elizabeth, because it says "Solved", are all of these submissions have been resubmitted on my my behalf? When it will be ready for the addition of the date of births from these reputable sources? I have already read the guidelines long time ago. Thanks Elizabeth for your reply.
Photo of Elizabeth

Elizabeth, Employee

  • 660 Posts
  • 1083 Reply Likes
Hi Ian,

To clarify this for you further: what you have provided here does not meet our guidelines regarding birth-date submissions. We recommend you review the guidelines again so you are up to date, paying close attention to this section: "We are looking for links to public records, printed publications, or official documents."
Photo of Tonko

Tonko

  • 3 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
ian_a a bit of advice and from my experience they require passports, birth certificates, drivers licences, public records issued by the state, not celebrity websites or social media.


Photo of ian_a

ian_a

  • 62 Posts
  • 21 Reply Likes
Social media is sometimes allowed. The guidelines have said "We do allow social media links to be an acceptable source for birthdates (i.e. Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, etc.)". For an example British newspaper The Sun is allowed for printed publications for its reputable sources.
(Edited)
Photo of Tonko

Tonko

  • 3 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
Yes I am aware what the 'guidelines' say however in reality this is not an acceptable source. DOB is the hardest of all data to add/edit. You should make yourself aware of the lawsuit between IMDb and the Sate of California.
Good luck with your efforts.
(Edited)
Photo of Nick Burfle

Nick Burfle

  • 108 Posts
  • 136 Reply Likes
Another possible source is that some states have their Registry of Vital Statistics online now and available to the public.  Probably doesn't help in California, though.